Journal field note
Worth it? The wooden pepper mill
Peugeot’s Paris u’Select adds a wooden body and base-ring adjustment. Whether those are worth paying for depends on the mill already in your kitchen.
Worth it? · by Tate
Marlowe’s question about the Peugeot in our pepper-mill edit: “Does dinner need a nicer pepper mill?” No. I might want one, which is a different answer and should probably come before the shopping.
What the upgrade actually adds
The existing comparison identifies this Paris u’Select as the chocolate-finish beechwood model, sold as 9 inches and specified at 22 cm. It has a steel pepper mechanism and six marked grind positions around the base. I like being able to return to a setting without remembering how far I turned a screw.
That is a preference about the controls, not a test result. The photograph here is an illustration of a worn wooden mill, not this Peugeot. I’m judging the linked model from the specifications and the limits set out in our comparison, not from a season of cooking with it.

The less expensive one already adjusts
Our comparison also covers the OXO Good Grips Contoured grinder: five settings on a sliding tab, a clear reservoir and a ceramic mechanism. So “adjustable grind” alone is not my reason to spend more. The Peugeot’s wooden form and base ring would have to be things I specifically wanted.
Nor would I count six settings against five and declare a winner. An extra marked position does not tell me whether I’ll prefer the pepper on my eggs. If your current mill gives you the texture you want without a fight, I’d leave it on the table.
What I would not pay for
A promise that the mill will never jam, or that the whole thing is covered forever. Our comparison notes reports of intermittent feeding and a split adjustment collar, alongside trouble-free experiences. It also distinguishes the lifetime mechanism warranty from the separate five-year manual-mill coverage, with conditions and exclusions. Read the current warranty before buying.
The wood needs dry care, and the refill opening asks for a little aim. A manual mill is also not my choice for producing a large quantity in a hurry. I want the nice object; I do not want to pretend it has no chores.
The verdict
Worth considering if you want this wooden shape and this adjustment layout enough to look after them. Not worth replacing a satisfactory mill just to improve the table photograph. Marlowe says that last sentence applies to photographers too. — T
Source: Our pepper-mill comparison: specifications, limitations and warranty distinction
- T