Some links on this page earn us a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
← Back to all favorites

This week's work ·

Late-summer tomatoes, mustard, and a tart worth leaving time for

A buttery crust, a layer of cheese and drained tomato slices, with a measured pepper finish and enough time for both pastry chills.

Activity Late-Summer Tomato Tart Yield One 9-inch tart, 6 servings Total 130 min
Marlowe in a white tee and denim apron lifts a golden tomato tart out of a baking sheet while Tate in a light blue chambray shirt holds a cooling rack, both looking at the tart with pleased expressions.

We can divide this tart between two jobs: one person makes the pastry while the other slices the tomatoes and sets them over a tray to drain. There is room for conversation without trying to roll dough, grate cheese and watch the oven at once. The mustard goes underneath the cheese; the thyme and pepper go over the tomatoes. Keep that order and the assembly is manageable.

The waiting deserves as much attention as the topping. This is a chilled pastry with a separate blind bake, not a quick tomato supper that starts when the oven goes on. Allow roughly two hours and ten minutes for the unhurried plan below, including both chills and an initial ten-minute cooling period. Preheating, rolling a stubborn dough or waiting for a safely handled pan can take longer.

Let the tomatoes drain while the dough chills

Use ripe tomatoes that will hold a slice. Set the quarter-inch rounds on a rack over a tray, then blot excess surface moisture before arranging them. This version drains them without extra salt: the measured half teaspoon of fine salt belongs in the pastry, and the flaky salt is a separate finish. Draining helps manage the filling's moisture; it is not a promise of a crisp base regardless of how juicy the tomatoes are.

Choose a proper nine-inch tart pan suitable for the oven temperature. A cake pan of the same nominal diameter is not automatically an equivalent replacement, particularly when it comes to removing the finished tart. Follow the pan's preparation and handling instructions. If it has a loose base, support it from underneath on a suitable baking sheet rather than lifting the hot rim alone.

The pepper is a small but deliberate part of the filling. Grind into a dry dish away from the oven, measure half a teaspoon and scatter it with the thyme before the final bake. That keeps a coarse setting from turning into an accidental extra spoonful. An existing mill or measured ground black pepper is enough; making this tart does not require buying a new grinder.

OXO for an adjustable everyday grinder

If a replacement mill is already on the kitchen list, the OXO Contoured Mess-Free Pepper Grinder is the mid-priced choice here. It has a clear acrylic reservoir, stainless steel accents and a ceramic grinding mechanism. A tab selects five grind settings, and the non-slip turning grip is a practical reason to consider it. The selected single grinder arrives with black peppercorns included.

Its grinding end sits at the top when stored upright; turn it over to grind. That layout helps keep stray grounds off the shelf between uses, while the clear body makes the remaining pepper easy to see. Comfortable turning and useful adjustment are genuine strengths, though neither a particular texture nor effortless operation suits every hand.

The refill closure is the compromise to inspect. It can be awkward to open or seat, and a closure that loosens can spill peppercorns. Other units refill without trouble, so check the actual fit rather than assuming either outcome. Low output and inconsistent grind are also possible frustrations. Five settings do not establish a measured dose per turn or guarantee that adjacent settings look very different. For this tart, use the measuring spoon rather than counting twists.

Peugeot for wood and a base-ring adjustment

The higher-priced alternative is the Peugeot Paris uSelect in chocolate-finish beechwood, 22 cm tall and marketed as the nine-inch size. It uses a case-hardened steel pepper mechanism and a base ring with six marked settings. This selected single mill comes without peppercorns.

Pay more if the wooden body, the feel of turning it and the separate adjustment ring are things you want to handle every day. They are tangible differences from the OXO's clear reservoir and tab. They do not establish better tomatoes, a more even pastry bake or a longer service life. The taller body also does not prove a larger usable pepper reservoir; there is no matched working-volume comparison here.

Peugeot's drawbacks matter alongside its appealing handling. Feeding can become intermittent, requiring stops and shaking, and refilling can be fiddly. The wooden adjustment collar can split. Smooth operation is also possible; the mixed outcomes rule out treating either effortless grinding or failure as inevitable. An extra setting is not a head-to-head output test.

Keep this wooden mill dry, use suitable dry whole peppercorns no larger than 6 mm and turn the head clockwise to grind. Wipe the outside with a soft dry cloth; follow the supplied guidance for emptying and brushing the mechanism. Do not wash it in water or use it for salt. Peugeot's US lifetime warranty concerns the mechanism, with separate five-year manual-mill coverage and conditions and exclusions. It is not a whole-object lifetime promise. OXO's Better Guarantee also has household-use, care and defect conditions; follow the selected grinder's supplied instructions rather than assuming it can go in the dishwasher.

Choose around the rest of your cooking

For a compact, visible-fill grinder with included peppercorns, consider the OXO, provided its closure and output are acceptable to you. Choose the Peugeot for wood and the base-ring control if its dry-care routine, refill arrangement and possible feeding or collar problems are acceptable. Neither removes the need to measure this recipe's half teaspoon. If the current grinder works, leave it on the counter and put the time into the pastry instead.

On a small screen, scroll the table sideways to compare both choices.

Which choice suits the work?
What matters OXO Good Grips Contoured Pepper Grinder, single The item this link opensPeugeot Paris u'Select pepper mill, chocolate, 22 cm / marketed 9-inch
Budgetmid-pricedhigher-priced
ConstructionClear acrylic reservoir, stainless-steel accents, ceramic grinding mechanism, non-slip gripChocolate-finish beechwood body with case-hardened steel pepper mechanism
Included piecesOne manual pepper grinder; peppercorns includedOne manual pepper grinder; peppercorns not included
Best fitCompact daily seasoning, visible fill level and top-grinding storageTraditional wooden form, smooth turning and marked ring adjustment
Worth knowingRefill closure can be awkward or loosen; inconsistent output and grind contrast; no lifespan promiseFinicky refill; intermittent feeding; wooden collar can split; higher price does not establish longer life
CareFollow supplied OXO care instructions; do not assume another mill's washing method appliesKeep dry; soft dry exterior cloth; empty and soft-brush mechanism; clockwise grinding; suitable peppercorns up to 6 mm, not salt
Grind settings56
AdjustmentSliding tabBase ring
Nominal heightNot specified here22 cm
Usable reservoir capacityNot established; height is not refill volumeNot established; height is not refill volume
WarrantyBetter Guarantee covers normal-household-use material/workmanship defects subject to care and product terms; refund requires original receiptLifetime mechanism coverage is distinct from the five-year manual-mill warranty; proof, care and exclusions apply
The OXO Contoured pepper grinder standing on a wooden counter beside a small bowl of peppercorns.
OXO Good Grips Contoured Pepper Grinder, single
The chocolate-brown Peugeot Paris u'Select pepper mill with its gold-tone knob, photographed on a plain white background.
Peugeot Paris u'Select pepper mill, chocolate, 22 cm / marketed 9-inch

See the exact item on Amazon

The item this link opensSee the exact item on Amazon

02 · The recipe

Late-Summer Tomato Tart

A buttery crust, a layer of cheese and drained tomato slices, with a measured pepper finish and enough time for both pastry chills.

Prep
30 min
Cook
45 min
Total
130 min
Yield
One 9-inch tart, 6 servings
Rest
45 min
Cool
10 min

Untested approximate plan:30activeprep+30firstchill+15secondchill+15blindbake+30toppedbake+10initialcool=130min. Rest is TWO pre-bake refrigerated chills, not post-cook standing. Tomato draining overlaps firstchill. Preheat/handling/doneness can extend. Ten minutes not safe-touch guarantee.

What you'll need

  • 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1/2 teaspoon fine sea salt
  • 1/2 cup cold unsalted butter, cubed
  • 1/4 cup ice water
  • 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard
  • 1 cup grated sharp cheddar or gruyere
  • 3 large ripe tomatoes, sliced 1/4-inch thick and drained on a rack
  • 1 teaspoon fresh thyme leaves
  • 1/2 teaspoon freshly cracked black pepper
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • Flaky sea salt, to finish

Useful equipment

  • Food processor used according to its instructions
  • Stable board and suitable knife
  • Rack and tray for draining tomatoes
  • Rolling pin and suitable rolling surface
  • Suitable oven-safe 9-inch tart pan, not assumed cake-pan equivalent
  • Suitable support baking sheet if loose-base pan
  • Dry oven mitts and heat-safe cooling rack/surface
  • Dry dish, measuring spoons and suitable spreading utensil
  • Existing pepper mill or ground black pepper

Method

  1. Keep the butter and cheese chilled until needed. Following the food processor's instructions, pulse the flour and the full 1/2 teaspoon fine salt together, then add the cold butter and pulse to pea-size crumbs. Add the ice water gradually, using only enough of the measured 1/4 cup for the dough to hold together when pressed. Form a disk, wrap and refrigerate for 30 minutes. Meanwhile, wash the tomatoes and slice on a stable board with a suitable knife; drain the slices on a rack over a tray without adding salt, then blot excess moisture. Keep fingers clear of the processor blade and disconnect it before handling the blade.
  2. Heat the oven to 400°F. Roll the dough to about a 12-inch round on a suitable surface and fit it into a prepared 9-inch tart pan without stretching; trim the edge. Refrigerate for another 15 minutes. Prick the base with a fork and blind-bake for about 15 minutes, until lightly golden. Follow the pan's instructions; support a loose-base pan on a suitable baking sheet and move it with dry oven mitts to a stable heat-safe surface.
  3. Carefully brush the warm crust with the full tablespoon of Dijon mustard and scatter the cup of grated cheese over the base. Keep the hot pan supported; do not press up against a loose base or hold its rim with bare hands.
  4. Arrange the drained, blotted tomato slices over the cheese in overlapping rows without piling them above the pastry edge. Scatter the teaspoon of thyme and the measured 1/2 teaspoon black pepper, then drizzle with the full tablespoon of olive oil. Grind and measure the pepper in a dry dish on the prep surface, not over the hot pan; a fixed turn count is not a measurement. If the tomatoes are unusually large, keep excess slices for another use rather than overfilling.
  5. Bake for a further 25–30 minutes, until the pastry is deep golden and the tomatoes have softened; extend as needed rather than relying on time alone. Move the supported pan to a heat-safe rack with dry oven mitts and cool for at least 10 minutes, longer as needed for safe handling and slicing. Ten minutes does not guarantee a cool pan. Add flaky salt sparingly after tasting a safely cooled bite, then serve warm. Refrigerate leftovers promptly rather than leaving the tart out for the afternoon; keep the pan supported if removing a loose base.

- T

More favorites

See every story